Photoshop
Advanced Black and White Conversion Techniques
Adapted from Black and White in Photoshop CS4 and Lightroom (Focal Press)
By Leslie Alsheimer and Bryan O'Neil Hughes
Dateline: May 15, 2009
Version: Adobe Photoshop CS4
More Photoshop tips
Discuss this in the Photoshop forum
Channel Mixer
Utilizing these founding color principles, the channel mixer puts theory into
action. With the same effect color filters produced, you can dynamically
interact with the translation of the spectral relationships between colors in
the conversion process by mixing the individual channels within a document.
The Channel Mixer tool allows you to control how much each of the three
color channels (Red, Green and Blue) contributes to the final grayscale
brightness. This method, therefore, has the ability to act as a digital set of
black and white filters, all in a single interface allowing you the flexibility and
power of having the whole color filter pack in post production.
The channel mixer has been traditionally and undoubtedly one of the most
powerful black and white conversion methods; however, it may take some
time to master since there are many parameters which require simultaneous
adjustment.
There are many ways to mix the channels in this process, and the “right” mix will
vary on a per image basis. Photoshop CS4 provides a few great presets to start
with (in fact you can save your own) but it is important to play with the mix
until you find a pleasing effect.

© Leslie Alsheimer


© Leslie Alsheimer
Pre-Channel Mixing:
Step 1: Open an image that is in RGB color mode.
Step 2: Analyze the channels (Note: this step is for viewing purposes only).
Open your Channels palette and click on the individual channels by clicking on
the words “Red,” “Green” and “Blue”. These different views will provide a guide for
how to customize the black and white conversion.
You will select the channel with the most detail and tonality to be the dominant
channel for the channel mixer on an image by image basis. The Red channel typically contains most of the detail in the image. The Blue channel typically contains the luminosity, skin tones and contrast but also frequently the most
noise. For this image, the Green channel was selected.
**Be sure you click back on the RGB letters at the top of the Channels
palette to return the image to color before moving to the next step.
Channel Mixer: The Method
Step 1: Choose Channel Mixer from the Adjustment panel, or from the Layers
palette, by clicking on the adjustment layer icon at the bottom of the Layers
palette.

Step 2: Check Monochrome
Check the box next to the word “Monochrome” in the lower left-hand side of
the Channel Mixer box. The image will immediately turn to grayscale.
The initial mixture predetermined by default, as of Photoshop CS3, opens with
Red 40%, Green 40% and Blue 20%. These better default values are actually
another cool new feature as of CS3, as CS2 used to just map to 100% Red.
Photoshop lessens the amount assigned to the Blue channel because the Blue
channel typically holds more noise than the other two channels of Red and
Green.
The advanced user may wish to monitor the Histogram palette in this process.
Step 3: Make Custom Changes
Adjust the Red, Green and Blue sliders to add and subtract amounts or
percentages of each channel to produce an image to your liking. The choices
made are purely aesthetic. The user has complete control of how each
channel will be represented in the final image outcome.
For an even more pronounced effect, some colors can even have negative
percentages.
It is advised that the percentage totals should not exceed 100%, when
all three channels are added, in order to maintain the density or overall
brightness of the image, although creative interpretation should always take
precedence over numbers. Experimenting with diff erent color settings will
enable you to find the combinations that your prefer. Be mindful though, if
the number totals do equate to over 100% there is a risk of losing highlight
information. Notice how cool Photoshop is to provide us with a Calculation
Total feature at the bottom of the channel sliders! So fabulous not to have to
do all that math on the fly!
Other cool new Channel Mixer features in Photoshop include the ability to
save, load and share settings and presets.
Note: Be careful of the Blue
channel as it typically
holds more noise than
the other two channels
of Red or Green. Unless
the goal is to create a
grainy-looking image
or some exaggerated
effect, it is best to steer
clear of using too much
Blue channel in the
mixture.
Step 4: Click OK when finished.
Note: Curiously, the image will
not return to Color if the
Monochrome button
is unchecked. To reset,
hold down the Option
key and the Cancel
button will turn to reset.
Step 7: Play!
There are as many interpretations of how an image can be conveyed as
there are number combinations within the tool. Create several different
interpretations and decide which one you prefer the best!
Note: A close approximation to
the luminosity perceived
by the human eye
would be settings of
red = 30%, green = 59%
and blue = 11%. An
approximation to the
default grayscale mode
change might be
red = 60%, green = 30%
and blue = 0%, and
a mix of red = 34%,
green = 33% and
blue = 33% is the
approximate equivalent
to desaturation.
Digital Like Film
For some digital photographers, the ultimate goal is to create black and white
digital images that look as if they were captured on film. The gritty quality
that came from pushed Kodak Tri-X film sometimes seems aesthetically so far
removed from the crisp digital files we see with today’s high resolution cameras.
There is a unique elegance in film’s simple grain and mysterious qualities. For
the film photographer, certain specialized looks have always been achieved
by choices in chemistry, paper and technique coupled with the type of film or
emulsion chosen. The varying diff erences in the consistency of light sensitivity
in emulsions typically give each type of film its unique aesthetic. With many
films being taken off the market today, it is still incredibly useful to keep those
traditional names and what they meant to the film photographer alive, and use
them as points of reference. For the black and white photographer, whether
traditional or digital, using black and white effectively is about choosing a
“look” that matches your image and intention.
Film stocks replicated from the Channel Mixer!
Of course, you will still have to add noise and grain to achieve the “look” of
some films.

Hue/Saturation Technique
This method, patented as “The Russell Brown Tonal Conversion Technique”,
lays the foundation for Photoshop’s latest Black and White stand-alone
feature. This method uses two Hue/Saturation adjustment layers to make the
initial conversion and creates a customized set of color mapping options at
the same time! How does it work?

© Leslie Alsheimer. Before

© Leslie Alsheimer. After
Step 1: Open an image you wish to convert, and click the Adjustment
panel and choose Hue/Saturation. You can also choose the Hue/Saturation
adjustment layer icon at the bottom of the Layers palette, or go to the Layer
Menu > New Adjustment Layer > Hue/Saturation. We are going to work
with this layer later. So when the dialog box comes up, do not make any
adjustments. Just click OK.
Hint: It is always a good idea
to name your layers!
Double-click on the
letters in the Layers
palette that spell out
“Hue/Saturation” and
type in a name like
“Color Mapping”. This
will help make it easy to
remember what each
layer does when you
come back to the image
later.

Step 2: Change the Blend mode of this new adjustment layer from Normal
to Color. This option is one of 20 or so available blend modes from the dropdown
menu in the Layers palette. This blend mode will allow us to adjust
the hue and saturation simultaneously. (If we think about this technique in
photographic terms, this layer will act as our Filter layer, or the Remapping
color layer.)

Step 3: Make another Hue/Saturation adjustment layer by clicking on the
Adjustments panel, or adjustment layer icon at the bottom of the Layers
palette and choosing Hue/Saturation a second time. This time, however, we
will pull the saturation slider all the way to the left, reducing the saturation
to –100 (in photographic terms again, this will be the “Film” layer, or simply
“convert to gray”).
Step 4: Now we are ready to create the black and white conversion
dynamically by playing with the individual color channels within the Hue/
Saturation dialog box’s drop-down menu. Here’s how...
Step 5: Double-click the adjustment layer thumbnail icon on the middle layer
in the stack, which is the “Filter” layer, or the first layer you created and set to
color. This will reopen the Hue/Saturation dialog box. Adjust the Hue slider
and notice how you are interactively changing the spectral relationships
between the colors as they translate into black and white. Isn’t that cool?
Step 6: You can also play with the Saturation slider and make further
adjustments to give more emphasis to tonal values within the image.

Step 7: This process actually gets better, believe it or not. If you go to the Edit
Menu in the very same dialog box and click on the drop-down menu, you
can change the “Master” composite to isolate each color separately. Pull both
the Hue and Saturation sliders for each color independently. Watch out for
unwanted posterization effects as this can happen fairly easily if you are not
paying attention.
Extra Bonus Tip! You can also expand
the color range of the
sliders by using the
eyedroppers. If you have
some red in the image
and you wish to add
yellow and green to that
adjustment area, select
the “Add” sample eyedropper
tool and simply
click on the colors you
wish to add, such as
blue and green. The tool
will expand the range
of colors and result in
better blending values.

© Leslie Alsheimer.
Turn Up the Volume! This One Goes to 11
Coined by Nigel from the film This is Spinal Tap, this pop culture phrase
commonly refers to anything capable of being exploited to its utmost abilities,
and to exceed them. In other words, it is the act of taking something to an
extreme. Coincidentilally Photoshop CS4, code name “Stonehenge”, also pays
homage to Spinal Tap. So this technique is an 11: The ADVANCED Maximize
Detail Combo Conversion Technique! To the MAX!
Once you have explored the fundamental conversion methods, you may be
ready to delve deeper into the conversion process. If you have not noticed yet,
converting to monochrome is most notably about re-establishing the spectral
relationships between color and tone within an image. The advanced printer
will know that image detail plays an integral role in successful black and white
fine art print making. Be warned this fancy technique takes a fair bit of time, is
not simple and can be incredibly confusing. It does, however, maximize your
control over the conversion process, whereby allowing the user to selectively
maximize detail and tonality in the conversion process. Althought there are a
few variations on this technique, no other method quite matches its power, as
this one really does go to 11!

© Leslie Alsheimer.

Step 1: Begin with an RGB image file processed optimally for color. Duplicate
your image. Image Menu > Duplicate. Open the channels palette and analyze
the channels by clicking on each of the individual channels in the Channels
palette. Do this several times and make notes on the differences in how
each channel translates the information and detail. For this
image, I noticed that there was more detail in the doorway (where the man is
standing) in the Blue channel, as well as in the top of the window. In the Green
channel, there was more information in the flowered curtains, the girl’s feet
on the bed, and the skirts they are wearing, as well as with the flip-flop on the
floor. The Red channel holds more detail in the empty beds.

Step 2: Convert the Duplicate Image to Lab mode.

Step 3: Go to the Channels palette and click on the Lightness Channel. Select
All > Edit Copy.

Step 4: Reactivate the original color image and create a new layer.
Layer > New Layer, or click on the new layer icon.
Step 5: Edit > Paste the Lightness channel into the new layer and rename the
layer “Lightness”.

Step 6: Create three more empty layers and rename them “Red,” “Green”
and “Blue.” You are going to copy and paste each of the Red, Green and Blue
channels into these layers.
Note: You will need to retarget
the Background layer
and the corresponding
channel each time you
want to copy a channel.
Step 7: Turn the visibility off on the Lightness channel by clicking on the
eyeball next to it in the Layers palette. This will ensure that the Lightness channel will not affect your channels. Copy and paste each channel into the
appropriate new layers you have just created.
You can make excellent conversions by simply lowering the opacity of
the different layers at this point. But who is stopping there? I said this one
goes to 11!

Step 8: Add a “Hide All” layer mask to each of the Red, Green and Blue
channels. Do this by holding the Option key as you click the “Add Layer Mask”
icon in the Layers palette, or simply use the Layer Menu > Add Layer Mask >
Hide All.
Step 9: Use a paintbrush, set to the default colors of black and white at
various opacities, and hide or reveal the diff erent aspects in which you noted.
I revealed the doorway on the Blue channel, the curtains, feet and skirt
on the green channel layer and the empty bed detail on the red channel
layer.

Try this technique with images shot in low light. The blue channel is great for
bringing out lost shadow detail. But be careful, as it also holds the most noise!
If you love this method, you may want to create a customized action in
Photoshop that sets up the layers for you to make the process a bit
faster. Visit the Santa Fe Digital Darkroom website for downloadable
actions coming soon.

© Leslie Alsheimer.
|