|
Photoshop Tips
Choosing the Right Colorspace For Your Digital Workflow
By Jay Kinghorn
Dateline: February 20, 2006
Version: Photoshop CS
More Photoshop tips
Discuss this in the Photoshop forum
|
 
|
Although some images may share
identical RGB values, their appearance
differs because every imaging device
responds to color stimuli differently.
The first square is from a Flextight
949 scanner, the second is from my
monitor, and the third is from a Light-Jet printer. To work efficiently, you
need a way to accurately preserve
color information from a digital camera
or scanner, through editing and
correction to a finished print. Color
management helps you do just that.
|
|
Here’s an experiment: Download the Colorspaces.zip archive, open the image Colorspaces1.tif, access the Info palette (F8), and move your
cursor over the window. The RGB values in the Info
palette will read 124, 16, 87. Duplicate the image two
times for a total of three images (Image > Duplicate).
Leave the first image in its native colorspace of Adobe
RGB (1998). With the first duplicate active, choose Image
> Mode > Assign Profile, and assign sRGB Profile as
the Destination Profile. On the second duplicate, assign
ColorMatch RGB as the Destination Profile. Using the
Info palette, verify that the RGB values for the three images
are identical even though the visual appearance of
all the squares is different.
|

|
Close the two duplicates, then duplicate the original image twice more. This
time, instead of assigning a new colorspace to the image, convert the color profiles to the new colorspace by choosing Image > Mode > Convert to Profile.
For the first duplicate, convert to the sRGB Profile. Under Conversion Options
choose Relative Colorimetric as the Intent, then check Use Black Point Compensation
and Use Dither, and click OK. Convert the second duplicate to Color-
Match RGB using the same settings for the Conversion Options as used earlier
in this step. If you check in the Info palette, you’ll see the RGB values for the
first duplicate change to 144, 16, 89, and the second duplicate’s RGB values
change to 119, 10, 73, yet their color appearances stay the same (Note: You
might have some value variations due to your own internal settings.)
The color behavior of a device such as a printer or scanner is measured and
stored in an ICC profile. At every stage in the imaging workflow, the profile
associated with an image tells Photoshop what colors should look like. When
an image moves from one portion of the workflow to another, say from RGB
editing to CMYK printing, the image is converted from the Source Space (RGB
editing space) to the Destination Space (CMYK printing) using the Convert to
Profile command. This accurately preserves the image’s color appearance at all
stages of the workflow.
|
|
It is recommended for RGB workflows to
convert images from an input space (digital
camera or scanner) to an editing space such as
Adobe RGB (1998), sRGB, or ColorMatch RGB.
These mathematically generated colorspaces are
optimal for tone and color correction, archiving,
and storage. The editing space you choose is
dictated by your workflow, and the devices you
commonly use for output. Adobe RGB (1998),
for example, is used for photography applications
such as advertising and fine art. The profile sRGB
is the best choice for images destined for the
Web and portrait photography. Both colorspaces
are shown in the ColorThink diagram. The
center axis represents the grayscale from black
to white. The further from the center a color
lies, the more saturated it is. Adobe RGB (1998)
is represented by the wireframe, and sRGB is the
solid. Notice the larger color gamut of Adobe
RGB (1998) particularly in the reds and greens.
CMYK-based workflows are generally tied to
a specific printing press or press condition,
e.g., a sheetfed press printing on coated paper.
Users should work in the colorspace that best
describes the file’s output destination.
Often, when images are converted from one
colorspace to another, some colors can’t be
faithfully reproduced because they lie outside
the destination’s color gamut. Photoshop’s
rendering Intent gives us the option of deciding
how gamut colors should be converted to the
new colorspace. Of the four rendering intents
used in Photoshop, only two are used commonly,
Relative Colorimetric and Perceptual.
|
|
Open Colorspaces2.tif Choose
the Convert to Profile command
and make sure Preview is checked.
Choose U.S. Sheetfed Coated v2
as the Destination Space and move
down in the dialog box to Conversion
Options. When the Relative
Colorimetric rendering Intent is chosen,
the appearance of the two colors
is unchanged. If Perceptual rendering
Intent is chosen, both colors become
slightly darker. Relative Colorimetric
rendering Intent is used for the majority
of images where overall color
accuracy is most important.
|
|
Now, open the file Colorspaces3.tif.
Again, open the Convert to Profile
dialog box and choose U.S. Sheetfed
Coated v2 as the Destination Space.
Notice that when Relative Colorimetric
is chosen as the Intent, the two red
squares are converted to the same
color. When the Perceptual rendering
Intent is used, the differences between
the two squares are preserved, although
the color accuracy of both squares is
compromised. The Perceptual rendering
Intent is used for image conversions
where saturated image detail is more
important than color accuracy.
|
|
Don't miss the next tip on Graphics.com. Get the free Graphics.com newsletter in your mailbox each week. Click here to subscribe.
|
Jay Kinghorn is a digital
workflow consultant based
in Boulder, Colorado.
|
|